Customer Comments
Product Reviews
Vintage Blacksmith Flatware Caddy
Three mango wood coffers are set inside a blackened iron frame to create this handsome caddy, perfect for sharing serving utensils, napkins and flatware. Curved handles make it easy to pass around the table. 14.5" wide x 4" deep x 5.5" high Made of mango wood with a wrought-iron stand that has a blackened finish. Caddies are removable. Monogramming is available at an additional charge. Monogram will be centered on one side of each canister. Catalog / Internet only.
Average Customer Rating
9 Comments 9
Sort by:
Customer Comments
Review 1 for Vintage Blacksmith Flatware Caddy
Average Customer RatingOverall Rating
mwmh
,Boston
,MA
mwmh
Average Customer RatingOverall Rating
Very cute
April 11, 2013
I had been looking for an attractive silverware caddy for a while and finally saw this. It is so cute! Love it.
Share this comment:
Review 2 for Vintage Blacksmith Flatware Caddy
Average Customer RatingOverall Rating
TRWAY1
,Northford
,CT
TRWAY1
Average Customer RatingOverall Rating
Does not come with FSK on it!
March 3, 2013
I love the concept of the letters FSK however I assumed that it came that way since all the pictures show it like that. I called PB to verify if it was monogrammed and they said it comes like that. I ordered it and was bummed that it arrived plain. PB needs to show a picture of it without the monogram so that customers can see that. PB ended up picking up my plain one and sending me a monogrammed one free of charge due to all the confusion. Unfortunately I went through 2 more caddies due to the monogrammed letters not being aligned at the same level and another one being scratched. In the end PB sent me a refund and I had to keep the scratched one. Not sure it's worth all the aggravation! Wish I had read the customer comment section all the way on the bottom of the page. In the end it is a really cute caddy and I'm very pleased with PB customer service!
Share this comment:
Review 3 for Vintage Blacksmith Flatware Caddy
Average Customer RatingOverall Rating
Pamela1
,Draper
,Ut
Pamela1
Average Customer RatingOverall Rating
Silverware Caddy
March 3, 2013
I was excited to find a silverware caddy that had character and a nice design. While I like this one and the black ironwork is nice, I was diappointed in the quality of the wood holders and mine were not engraved with the "S", "F", "K" letters. I expect better quality when purchasing from Pottery Barn.
Share this comment:
Review 4 for Vintage Blacksmith Flatware Caddy
Average Customer RatingOverall Rating
Jessica0409
,Hebron
,CT
Jessica0409
Average Customer RatingOverall Rating
Really Nice
March 2, 2013
My kitchen is small so I ordered this partly to save on my drawer space and partly to make it easier for my daughter to set the table. Also, who hasn't "just sat down" and one of your kids says they are missing a fork or dropped it on the floor? The boxes did have some scratches on them but when I put them in the caddy the metal strips hid them so it must have been a bad packaging issue. I did read the previous reviews and had it engraved with the f,s&k and it looks just as pictured. It's really beautiful- you wont be disapointed.
Share this comment:
Review 5 for Vintage Blacksmith Flatware Caddy
Average Customer RatingOverall Rating
dianepj
,bloomfield hills
,mi
dianepj
Average Customer RatingOverall Rating
disappointed
January 28, 2013
I wish that I had read these comments before ordering this item. The piece is very nice, but I was shocked that the f,s,and k were not on the boxes. I would not consider this to be a monogram, and I wondered if they considered it 3 charges or one to duplicate what was pictured. Pottery Barn is normally much better about clarifying things.
Share this comment:
Review 6 for Vintage Blacksmith Flatware Caddy
Average Customer RatingOverall Rating
reneeinaz117
,scottsdale
,az
reneeinaz117
Average Customer RatingOverall Rating
utensil holder
January 23, 2013
When I saw the picture with the f, k, s on the item, I thought that is how it came. Didn't not realize that you had to have that put on as a MONOGRAM. I was very disappointed.
Share this comment:
Review 7 for Vintage Blacksmith Flatware Caddy
Average Customer RatingOverall Rating
jen38
,Shirley
,MA
jen38
Average Customer RatingOverall Rating
Nice product, but...
January 22, 2013
I bought this as a christmas gift for someone who requested it. It is very nice, but you should be aware that it does not come with the "s" "f" and "k" on the boxes. If you want them you have to opt for the monograming. This was not clear from the description and surprised both me and the person I gave it to.
Share this comment:
Review 8 for Vintage Blacksmith Flatware Caddy
Average Customer RatingOverall Rating
ChristieN
,Portland
,OR
ChristieN
Average Customer RatingOverall Rating
Does NOT come standard with engraved letters!
December 26, 2012
I wish I had read the comments here before ordering! Beautiful piece, but came without the 'f' 's' and 'k' that are shown in the photo. That was a big reason I purchased it, and it is too much work to return it for engraving now.
Share this comment:
Review 9 for Vintage Blacksmith Flatware Caddy
Average Customer RatingOverall Rating
COtter
,Virginia Beach
,VA
COtter
Average Customer RatingOverall Rating
Perfect counter storage
August 29, 2012
I love this caddy. It is very expensive looking and I didn't think was too bad on the price. It is perfect for all my silverware. Only thing which was my fault, I didn't notice that I had to have them engraved. They came blank and I was a little upset. Just a fair warning. It is a beautiful piece.
Share this comment:
