Customer Comments
Product Reviews
Eclectic Silver-Plated Candlesticks
The dramatic displays of candlelight once reserved for grand hotels make a festive gift or striking addition to your own tabletop, mantle or console.Plated in silver.Watch a video about how to create a beautiful {{link path='/stylehouse/videos/videos/pp_v29_rel.html?cm_sp=Video_PIP-_-HOLIDAY-_-AFFORDABLE_HOLIDAY_DISPLAY' class='popup' width='950' height='300'}}holiday display{{/link}}.
Average Customer Rating
21 Comments 21
7 of 11(64%)reviewers recommend this product to a friend.
Sort by:
Customer Comments
Review 1 for Eclectic Silver-Plated Candlesticks
Average Customer RatingOverall Rating
Okypoky
,Champlain
,NY
Okypoky
Average Customer RatingOverall Rating
Worse PB purchase
April 14, 2013
I buy a lot of stuff from PB and this is buy far the most disappointing purchase I have made. The candlesticks in the picture are beautiful and exactly what I wanted for my mantel. The candlesticks I received, however, were a big disappointment. As soon as I took them out of the box they were already TARNISHED. They have been on my mantel for about 3 months and they have TURNED BLACK. I'm sure if I took the time to polish them they would be back to being beautiful but with 3 kids under the age of 3 I barely have time to shower never mind polish candlesticks. I would only suggest that a "warning" be added in the description to make buyers aware that these require some maintenance. I would recommend these for a person who stays at home and enjoys spending time taking care of their nicknacks but would advise any busy mom to stay away from these.
Share this comment:
Review 2 for Eclectic Silver-Plated Candlesticks
Average Customer RatingOverall Rating
sayler23
,Mandeville
,LA
sayler23
Average Customer RatingOverall Rating
Wow, Love these...
February 15, 2013
For low cost, cheaper candlestick holders that look attracitve...These are great. Classic styling...clean lines. I really love these. And they look great on my (or any) table. Such a great addition to my table. Happy I made the purchase.
Share this comment:
Review 3 for Eclectic Silver-Plated Candlesticks
Average Customer RatingOverall Rating
RidgefieldNan
,Ridgefield
,WA
RidgefieldNan
Average Customer RatingOverall Rating
Perfect!
February 10, 2013
Just the size and shape I was looking for. Arrived well packed. They have a lovely sheen.
Share this comment:
Review 4 for Eclectic Silver-Plated Candlesticks
Average Customer RatingOverall Rating
ArlingtonVA
,Arlington
,VA
ArlingtonVA
Average Customer RatingOverall Rating
Tarnish too easily
December 16, 2012
I had the same problem as many reviewers here (though I didn't read the comments until after I had already purchased.) Some were tarnished while still in the box, so I purchased the store-recommended silver polish which STILL couldn't get all the tarnish off of one of them. Two days later they were all tarnished again. Back to the store they went. Too bad since they were so pretty.
Share this comment:
Review 5 for Eclectic Silver-Plated Candlesticks
Average Customer RatingOverall Rating
bakingbride
,Chicago
,IL
bakingbride
Average Customer RatingOverall Rating
Tarnish easily.
September 10, 2012
wish I hadn't registered for these candlesticks. They tarnish within one day of sitting out, as do the rest of the silver plated items in the Pottery Barn collection. Get the mercury glass candlesticks instead.
Share this comment:
Review 6 for Eclectic Silver-Plated Candlesticks
Average Customer RatingOverall Rating
Large silver candelsticks
January 21, 2012
I used two of these candlesticks for my Christmas Eve dining room table on either sides of my centerpiece. I used white pillar candles and the light from the Christmas tree next to the table, and played soft Christmas music. They helped create a elegant, special atmosphere for my family.
Share this comment:
Review 7 for Eclectic Silver-Plated Candlesticks
Average Customer RatingOverall Rating
Rappitemom
,New Harmony
,IN
Rappitemom
Average Customer RatingOverall Rating
Absolutely gorgeous!
January 6, 2012
I have been very pleased with Pottery Barn merchandise in the past, but these candlesticks are much nicer than I even expected! They are weighty and look almost like solid silver! Very pleased with my purchase! I would love to see more products with this finish!
Share this comment:
Review 8 for Eclectic Silver-Plated Candlesticks
Average Customer RatingOverall Rating
Ozze
,Chicago
,IL
Ozze
Average Customer RatingOverall Rating
Stylish Candlestics
October 17, 2011
This candlestick ise very elegant with its simple and classic design. It can dress up any mantle or table arrangement. I would highly recommend them.
Share this comment:
Review 9 for Eclectic Silver-Plated Candlesticks
Average Customer RatingOverall Rating
Dizziegal
Long Island, NY
Dizziegal
Long Island, NY
Average Customer RatingOverall Rating
Using for our wedding ceremony
May 25, 2011
These candlesticks are beautiful and heavy. They will make a great addition to our wedding ceremony for our unity candle lighting.
Share this comment:
Review 10 for Eclectic Silver-Plated Candlesticks
Average Customer RatingOverall Rating
Jannne
Avon, CT
Jannne
Avon, CT
Average Customer RatingOverall Rating
bridal gift
May 18, 2011
Received a nice thank you note from the bride. It was on her registry, so I assume she liked it.
Share this comment:
Review 11 for Eclectic Silver-Plated Candlesticks
Average Customer RatingOverall Rating
WorkingProfessional
NJ
WorkingProfessional
NJ
Average Customer RatingOverall Rating
Polished out!
January 7, 2011
Absolutely loved the look of these candlesticks and bought 4 for a fireplace display. The looked fantastic for the first 2 days, by the end of the first week they were starting to tarnish. I've polished and used a protector on them but the tarnish came back shortly. I tried to see what they would look like unpolished - awful brownish black tarnish, which does not look vintage, just dirty. I have since polished them more times than I can count, certainly every time before I have company. I'm sure there are people out there who would enjoy meticulously polishing silver once a week, but I've learned that I'm not one of them. Wish these candlesticks came in a matte finish.
1 of 1 found this review helpful.
Share this comment:
Review 12 for Eclectic Silver-Plated Candlesticks
Average Customer RatingOverall Rating
Arizona1029
Arizona
Arizona1029
Arizona
Average Customer RatingOverall Rating
Great Value
January 7, 2011
Nice addition to my collection. Substantial, excellent quality, and lovely to boot!
Share this comment:
Review 13 for Eclectic Silver-Plated Candlesticks
Average Customer RatingOverall Rating
jazmine
arlington VA
jazmine
arlington VA
Average Customer RatingOverall Rating
Silver taper candles
December 7, 2010
Surprise to see these selling again. Bought them years ago and eventually threw them out as they kept tarnishing and i was not able to do so for a couple of months. they actually turned black
2 of 2 found this review helpful.
Share this comment:
Review 14 for Eclectic Silver-Plated Candlesticks
Average Customer RatingOverall Rating
NAT22
illinois
NAT22
illinois
Average Customer RatingOverall Rating
tarnish.
December 3, 2010
i bought the small tapers for my table and had them home for about a week before they started to tarnish. i proceeded to polish them with a well known product and not even 2 weeks later they began to tarnish again. i know that silver does need polishing, but after polishing and it tarnishing again that quickly, i just don't have the time to keep up with that. they are just sittting on my dining room table, so i don't know why they are tarnishing so quickly, but i would not recommend buying them if you don't want to be polishing twice a month.
1 of 1 found this review helpful.
Share this comment:
Review 15 for Eclectic Silver-Plated Candlesticks
Average Customer RatingOverall Rating
hilron
wilmington, de
hilron
wilmington, de
Average Customer RatingOverall Rating
beautiful candlesticks
November 23, 2010
I love my new candlesticks, i have them on a shelf with some family pictures and they look great against my blue living room wall. they are the perfect size/height for the narrow shelf and very sturdy and shiny...love them!
Share this comment:
Review 16 for Eclectic Silver-Plated Candlesticks
Average Customer RatingOverall Rating
kcbride
MI
kcbride
MI
Average Customer RatingOverall Rating
Beautiful Candlesticks
November 10, 2010
I received the Silver-Plated Taper Holder (Small) from my wedding registry. I LOVE them! They are beautiful and can be used for many occasions.
Share this comment:
Review 17 for Eclectic Silver-Plated Candlesticks
Average Customer RatingOverall Rating
Nobagger
Denver, CO
Nobagger
Denver, CO
Average Customer RatingOverall Rating
Long Tall and Lean Silver
October 4, 2010
Beautiful Tall Slim candle Holders. beautiful design can be contemporary or traditional. These are behind my sofa on a long table mixed with other silver plate and sterling and they look fabulous! Fit Right In.
They are a great size for height and can be used on the table during dinner because they are so slim. I would buy more if I had another place to put them :)
Moderatley heavy
They are a great size for height and can be used on the table during dinner because they are so slim. I would buy more if I had another place to put them :)
Moderatley heavy
1 of 1 found this review helpful.
Share this comment:
Review 18 for Eclectic Silver-Plated Candlesticks
Average Customer RatingOverall Rating
Miamiliving
Miami, FL
Miamiliving
Miami, FL
Average Customer RatingOverall Rating
Classic and Elegant
August 10, 2010
I LOVE these! I can't express it any other way. I have them all except one of the taper holders. Yes you do have to polish them give or take every 3 or 6 months but they are silver what do you expect? They have a vintage feel because of the varying shapes some feel feminine some masculine but have the elegance of true silver. I've used mercury glass and krome pillar holders in the past and they don't compare to the elegnace and style these have. Love it! Love it! Love it!
3 of 3 found this review helpful.
Share this comment:
Review 19 for Eclectic Silver-Plated Candlesticks
Average Customer RatingOverall Rating
LindaK
Tampa, FL
LindaK
Tampa, FL
Average Customer RatingOverall Rating
Silver Candlesticks--all that glitters!
May 14, 2010
These candlesticks so impressed me that I bought every one, some of them two of each! They are so versatile and work well with nearly all the table settings, mantel displays, etc. Mine have served in big ways at a bridal shower, in small ways for just every day use. They add an air of elegance to holidays and beyond--often times they are the show! I've experienced no issues with tarnish, which motivated me to keep buying until I had the whole collection. I am thrilled with these little jewels!
3 of 3 found this review helpful.
Share this comment:
Review 20 for Eclectic Silver-Plated Candlesticks
Average Customer RatingOverall Rating
decorator
FL
decorator
FL
Average Customer RatingOverall Rating
Gorgeous
May 7, 2010
I bought the largest one of these and didn't have the problems at all that the reviewer below had. I have bought many silver-plated items from Pottery Barn and just use a good polisher and protector. (I use Tarni-Shield.) I expect to have to polish anything silver that I have, but only have to polish my PB silver once every 6 months or so. What I like about these candles is that they're not the cold chrome-like look, but rather the warmer, true silver look. I'll be buying more! Thanks for another great product, PB!
4 of 4 found this review helpful.
Share this comment:
